Make us your home page

At 'American Idol' auditions in Orlando, there are life lessons in line

LAKE BUENA VISTA — From her spot across the lawn, Sasha Orihuela studies her son.

Jeremy Joshua Dorsey is laughing at the front of the line, flipping his bottle of water, fanning himself with his palm. He doesn't look nervous, but then, he is 16. He never does.

Orihuela pulls out her phone.

Go over your song, she texts. Start going over your words.

No response. She calls him twice. He doesn't answer.

"Yep. He's ignoring me. It begins. This is the hard part."

It's all hard, this day. Orihuela and Jeremy were up at 5 a.m. to haul from West Tampa to Lake Buena Vista for the first day of auditions for ABC's reboot of American Idol. Up to 4,000 singers would wait hours in 90-degree heat for a chance to audition in tents at Disney Springs. Just as many moms, dads, loves, siblings, managers and well-wishers bit their nails nearby.

Every now and then, a voice pierces the heat — an intimidating, belt-it-out warble, the kind that has earned singers like Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood tickets to Hollywood.

"Ooh," Orihuela gasps as a young woman wails. "Oh my gosh, that's beautiful."

Orihuela once again checks her Samsung.

"Your mother's freaking out," she says, watching Jeremy off in the distance. "Please answer your phone."

• • •

American Idol's luster has dimmed in recent years. Its last few champions have tanked, at least in comparison to past breakout stars like Jennifer Hudson or Adam Lambert. Ratings plummeted, and so did water cooler interest. Viewers turned to The Voice and America's Got Talent.

REMEMBER WHEN: Once a pop culture king, 'American Idol' shrinks with its tour

But Idol is still Idol "it still has a ring," Orihuela said. "It's the singing competition."

When Fox dropped American Idol last spring, a bidding war arose among the other networks to snap it up. ABC emerged victorious, its reboot featuring Katy Perry and two other unnamed judges set to premiere early next year. Disney was an obvious place to launch auditions; former Idol champs Jordin Sparks, Ruben Studdard and Kris Allen were on hand to drum up publicity.

Joe Burbank/Orlando Sentinel via AP

American Idol stars, from left, Ruben Studdard, Jordan Sparks and Kris Allen cut the ribbon during auditions for American Idol.

For years, Jeremy talked about singing for Simon Cowell, even after Cowell left the show. Idol premiered the summer after he was born; he's never really known a life without it. Idol was just one way to make a living singing.

Jeremy attends Blake High School, Tampa's magnet for the arts; and studies voice and performance at Hands in Motion Music, a talent development, management and publicity boutique in Brandon. That's how the Idol audition came about — the show's casters put out a nationwide call for young talent, with those pre-selected, like Jeremy, receiving front-of-the-line passes.

Slight with intense eyes and curly hair dyed blond, Jeremy is often taken for much younger. He just had a Harry Potter-themed birthday party; he has yet to apply for his learner's permit. But on stage, under the moniker JJosh, he emulates flashier heroes like Prince and former Idol finalist Todrick Hall. When he was younger, he would moonwalk in church. He once made a fingerless glove from backpack netting and the strap from his mother's purse. He wanted to bring it to Orlando. Orihuela talked him out of it.

Before a producer insists they separate — singers in line, parents in the shade — Orihuela retrieves a packet of paperwork. Jeremy breaks from texting friends and snapping photos, and leans on a trash can to consider a questionnaire.


Jeremy Joshua Dorsey, 16, of Tampa looks at supportive messages on his phone ahead of his audition for American Idol.

How has your community supported you? What well-known singer(s) do people compare you to? Are you closely related or a good friend with someone who is famous?

Orihuela laughs. She drives Lyft for a living; before that she taught English as a second language; before that, the Marines. They live with her mother and Orihuela's 18-year-old daughter.

Famous friends? "I wish," she says.

SOUNDCHECK: Tampa Bay concert news and more

Orihuela, 45, is adamant about not becoming a stage mom. "Don't be Joe Jackson" — that's her motto. She is protective. Her first daughter died after a medical treatment she says resulted from a misdiagnosis. After that, she homeschooled Jeremy for three years.

But at some point, you still have to stand back.

"That's your questionnaire, baby, not mine," Orihuela tells him. "You handle it. It's your story."

• • •

There's an emergency. Jeremy forgot to bring his questionnaire packet to producers.

"Give me the sheet!" Jeremy pants, racing from the front of the line. "I need the sheet right now!"

Orihuela pulls the packet from her purse. Jeremy grabs it and races back.

Orihuela swipes through baby photos on her phone. There's one with Jeremy at six months, turning away from his hugging sisters. Always doing his own thing.

It would be wonderful if Jeremy made it to Hollywood, but the way she sees it, the Idol audition process isn't about that. It's a test: How many singers — how many parents — are willing to sweat out this first, difficult step? And how many will take the next? And the step beyond that?

"Raising kids has been like that," Orihuela says. "They're always going to test your boundaries and see how far they can go, and then they grow from there. And then they test again, to see how far they can go, and then you go on from there. That's kind of what I'm trying to instill in him. A lot of what we go through in life is testing you to see if you can make it to the next level."


Jeremy Joshua Dorsey, 16, of Tampa auditions for American Idol.

In the tent, Jeremy sings Bruno Mars' That's What I Like. It's over in minutes. His whole group walks away empty-handed. When he sees his mother, he shakes his head.

"They said that we were good," he says. "It's just the energy wasn't what they needed."

"Ah," Orihuela said. "All right, then. I guess I've got to give you coffee next time, huh?"


It's not yet noon, but it's time to go home. Jeremy wants a strawberry lemonade. Orihuela wants a nap. The drive west to Tampa is about 90 minutes. Hollywood will take a little longer.

At 'American Idol' auditions in Orlando, there are life lessons in line 08/17/17 [Last modified: Thursday, August 17, 2017 4:54pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Fresh figs take a starring role in this fig cake


    Figs are showy fruit.

    They can't help themselves. Even the plainest, drabbest fig will reveal a scarlet belly, flecked with shimmering seeds, once you take a bite. Whether they're sliced or halved, arranged in a tart shell, on a crostini or just on a plate, there are few visions more enticing. This is why most fig …

    Chopping fresh figs and folding them into cake batter is not something you usually see, but that’s exactly what happens in this recipe for fig cake.
  2. As Faith Hill and Tim McGraw come to Tampa, here's why their love fascinates and endures

    Music & Concerts

    Eight years ago, Tim McGraw and Faith Hill stood on the sidelines of Raymond James Stadium, waiting for Hill's cue to perform America the Beautiful before Super Bowl XLIII. He held her hand and they kissed as the Steelers, Cardinals and a television audience of 150 million waited in the wings.

    Faith Hill and Tim McGraw perform during the “Soul2Soul” World Tour at Staples Center on July 14 in Los Angeles.
  3. From the food editor: Five things I'm enjoying in the food world right now


    Sometimes your notebook is scribbled with little thoughts here and there, things you come across in the food world and want to share but aren't sure how or when. Well, folks, I need to get some of this off my chest. Here is a somewhat random collection of culinary things I am really enjoying right now:

    Espresso Sea Salt Cookie Sandwiches with a cooked buttercream frosting, from St. Petersburg home bakery Wandering Whisk Bakeshop. Photo by Jennifer Jacobs.
  4. Michael McDonald and Kenny Loggins: Yacht rock paradise at the Clearwater Jazz Holiday

    Music & Concerts

    Frosty wine coolers and a misty sunset sea breeze. White linen pants and a tilted captain's hat. Coconut milk and an awful lot of rum.

    Kenny Loggins performs during Little Kids Rock Benefit 2016 at Capitale on October 5, 2016 in New York City.
  5. New podcast: Songs for an '80s Halloween playlist


    It has to start with Thriller, right? No spooky song playlist from the '80s omits the Michael Jackson classic. Well, our list doesn't. (Though we do give Thriller its due.) Instead, this week's podcast aims for picking some more unusual tunes. (Okay, and a few obvious ones too.)